Furniture You Have to Feel to Believe
No picture or online description can capture the true luxury of fine, hand-crafted furniture. At Simply Amish Indianapolis, we invite you to experience it for yourself.
When you step into our Indianapolis showroom, you’re not just browsing furniture – you’re immersing yourself in a tradition of Midwestern craftsmanship and genuine hospitality. Our goal isn’t to sell you a piece of furniture; it’s to welcome you into the family and help you discover something truly special for your home. The difference is something you can literally feel, and we can’t wait for you to experience it.
Run your hand over the silky-smooth finish and you’ll feel the care of handcrafted, made-to-order furniture built just for you in the heartland of America.
Open a drawer and you’ll feel the difference—solid hardwood, dovetail joints, soft-close slides, and craftsmanship so personal, each piece is signed by its maker.
Sit, recline, and feel the solid wood frames and plush cushions—comfort you can see and truly feel for yourself.
In our natural showroom light, you can truly see and feel the rich wood grains and premium fabrics that screens simply can’t capture.
Ready to Experience It? Plan Your Visit Today
Your search for the perfect furniture isn’t complete until you’ve experienced Simply Amish in person. We genuinely believe that once you feel the difference, you’ll never want to go back to browsing pictures on a screen or settling for assembly-line furniture. It’s time to treat yourself to the real thing.
Visiting our showroom is easy and we’re here to help you make the most of it. You can schedule a free design consultation if you’d like dedicated time with one of our designers (just give us a call or book online), or simply drop by at your convenience – we love surprise visits! Our Indianapolis showroom is conveniently located in the Castleton area (4505 East 82nd Street, right off I-465) with plenty of parking and open hours every day of the week.
A Different Kind of Furniture Store Experience
Personalized Attention
The moment you walk in, we’ll welcome you and get to know what brings you by. If you have an appointment, we’ll be ready for you. If not, we’ll happily show you around or let you explore freely – your choice.
Relaxed Atmosphere
No rushing, no crowds, no blaring music or overwhelming aisles. Take all the time you need. Sit in every chair, compare wood samples side by side, and soak in the design inspiration. We’re here to answer questions when you’re ready.
Expert Help On Hand
If you want guidance, our designers will be on standby. They can offer quick tips or deep dives – even a whole-home design chat – whatever level of help you desire. Remember, this consultation is completely free and with no obligation.
A Warm Send-Off
Before you go, we’ll make sure you have any information you need – wood samples, fabric swatches, measurements, or a quote for the custom piece you fell in love with. And of course, an invitation to come back anytime. (Don’t be surprised if we send you off with a few extra cookies for the road!)
Meet Our Designers
Julie Brogden-The Creative Soul
Julie has 19+ years of retail sales and management experience. She is passionate about cultivating a unique customer experience and prides herself on her service skills. “Everyday is a new day" is her main philosophy and this helps to keep innovation and the main goals forefront, despite ever changing environments in the industry.
Jill Warren-The Detail Whisperer
Jill Ulmer Warren has been a Design Consultant for Simply Amish Furniture for 16 years. "What an awesome job I have. I make new friends every day, helping them create their own family heirloom and I get to be a part of it! I do not sell, I assist in their decisions! How blessed is that?"
Susan Lowder-The Cozy Creator
Susan has an unwavering passion for interior design and a natural flair for building connections. She loves transforming spaces into personalized works of art by collaborating with each client to achieve their desired outcome.